Moving RPKI Beyond Routing Security

Resource Tagged Attestations, or RTAs, are a new type of RPKI object that is being proposed by authors from APNIC and NLnet Labs in the IETF. They allow any arbitrary file to be signed ‘with resources’ by one or more parties.

Moving RPKI Beyond Routing Security

By Tim Bruijnzeels

Resource Public Key Infrastructure (RPKI) is used for improving Border Gateway Protocol (BGP) routing security. Often the terms RPKI, ROA (Route Origin Authorisation) and ROV (Route Origin Validation) are used interchangeably.

But did you know that, in fact, the term RPKI refers to the Resource Public Key Infrastructure only? It is the basic infrastructure that allows resource holders to make signed statements about their Internet number resources. And while routing security is the primary use case for RPKI, there are many other interesting statements that one may want to make about one’s IP addresses or Autonomous Systems Numbers (ASNs)!

Resource Tagged Attestations, or RTAs, are a new type of RPKI object that is being proposed by authors from APNIC and NLnet Labs in the IETF. They allow any arbitrary file to be signed ‘with resources’ by one or more parties. The RTA object is a separate file that cryptographically connects the document with a set of resources. The receiver of the object can use an RPKI validator to show these resources, and verify that it was created by the rightful holder(s) of those resources.

The file can be anything. Interpreting what the resources mean in relation to the content of the file is not part of the RTA specification itself. For example, the file could be a pdf document that is meant to be read by humans, such as a letter of authority, and the reader can then verify that the resources match the content. But this can also be used by machines. For example, for bring-your-own-ip-prefix (BYOIP) functionality offered by some cloud providers, they could ask a user for a specific piece of data (such as the account number) to be signed and process their RTA as proof of holdership.

Create and validate RTA objects today

As a part of the RTA development effort, NLnet Labs has now introduced proof-of-concept support for this in Routinator and Krill, which is interoperable with the RTA signing function in development at APNIC.

Because it is still early days in the development of this standard we have not yet added this support by default. However, if you want to experiment with RTA today, you can install special versions of Routinator and Krill on a test machine and get your hands dirty.

Step 1: Build Krill and Routinator with RTA support

Install Routinator and Krill using Cargo. For this, you can follow the directions on installing Rust on your system described here. But explicitly enable the rta feature when you build the binaries:

cargo install routinator --features rta
cargo install krill --features rta

Step 2: Set up a test Krill instance under the NLnet Labs testbed

We will assume that you will run Krill on a test machine where you have shell access. At this time RTA support has not yet been added to the user interface, so we will use the krillc Command Line Interface (CLI) client here.

Choose a secret token and CA Name and set the following environment variables:


Choose a working directory and set the following environment variable:

mkdir -p $KRILL_DIR

Configure and run Krill:

krillc config simple --data $KRILL_DIR \ 
                     --logfile $KRILL_DIR/krill.log \ 
                     --token $KRILL_CLI_TOKEN > $KRILL_DIR/krill.conf
nohup krill -c $KRILL_DIR/krill.conf &

Create your CA

krillc add

Set up your CA using the NLnet Labs test service as a parent and repository.

To add the Publication Server, generate a request XML file:

krillc repo request

Then copy and upload it under "Register Publisher" here:

Next, copy the response and put in a file on your system, here we will use ca-repo-res.xml as the filename. Then add the repository to your CA:

krillc repo update --response ./ca-repo-res.xml

To add the testbed parent to your CA generate a request file and upload it under the “Register CA” tab of the same url as above. You can choose any resources for testing. Here we will use:

krillc parents request

Copy the response and put in a file on your system. Here we will use ‘ca-par-res.xml’ as the filename. Then add the parent to your CA:

krillc parents add --parent testbed --response ./ca-par-res.xml

Wait a couple of seconds for Krill to synchronise with the parent and publish to the repository. Then verify its status with the show command. You should now see something like this:

krillc show 
Name:     ca

Base uri: rsync:// 
RRDP uri: 

ID cert PEM: 

Hash: f988a5af965f3ef3137653ac2f400fc50265121ff1ea9b6bb317c66845669a8d

Total resources:

Handle: testbed Kind: RFC 6492 Parent

Resource Class: 0
Parent: testbed
State: active    Resources:

Current objects:


Step 3: Sign an RTA

Now we can start signing any file we like. Here we will sign the Krill configuration file that you just created. But, of course, feel free to sign cat videos if you want!

krillc rta sign --ipv4 \
                --days 365 \ 
                --name RTA1 \ 
                --in $KRILL_DIR/krill.conf

To show your RTAs you can use the following:

krillc rta list

You can save an RTA to disk as follows:

krillc rta show --name RTA1 --out $KRILL_DIR/krill.conf.rta

Step 4: Validate

Since we are running our Krill under the NLnet Labs testbed, you will need to configure Routinator to use its TAL:

mkdir ~/.rpki-cache/tals
cd ~/.rpki-cache/tals
cd - 

Now anyone can validate that the signature matches the file, in this case provided that they added the NLnet Labs testbed TAL as described above. If the signature is valid, Routinator will report the resources covered by it:

routinator -q rta ./krill.conf ./krill.conf.rta

Future work

APNIC and NLnet Labs plan to update the RTA document and seek standardisation in the IETF. When the standard becomes more crystallised we plan to give this more prominent support in Krill, for example, by adding a user interface to manage RTAs under your CA.